Does “Removing God from School” Invite Tragedy?

After the horrific mass shooting in Newtown Connecticut, in which 20 children and 6 adults the gunman and his mother were killed, I have heard numerous people make the argument that this is what happens when you take God out of schools. Apparently it’s not the shooter who is responsible for these tragic deaths but those of us who had the audacity to remove the Christian God from our public schools. I have heard this argument made numerous times concerning other events as well, including more recent ones.

There is so much wrong with this argument, I hardly no where to begin. First, off no one removed God from any school. If, we assume for the sake of conversation that the Christian God or something like him exists, it would be impossible for mere mortals to escort him out of a school, or any other building for that matter. Supposedly, his powers are infinitely greater than those of us ordinary humans, and many believe him to be omnipresent. The very idea of removing an omnipresent being from any location is absurd.

What us secularist did do was remove government imposed religious instruction from tax-payer funded schools. When religious conservatives say we took God out of schools, it is code for the fact that the heavy hand of Government is no longer using other people’s tax money to shove Christian religious beliefs down the throats of other people’s children. I cannot help but think this governmental restraint is a good thing. Freedom of religion means that government doesn’t force religious instruction on the people. People are still free to teach children about their God in their homes, in religious private schools and in their churches, free from the encroachment of government and the use of other people’s tax money.

But even though public school teachers are no longer allowed to or required to push religious instruction, it still does not mean God has been taken out of schools. Children are still allowed to pray, they just cannot be instructed to do so by a school official. Children are also free to join religious clubs, read religious texts in their free time and talk among themselves about religious topics. We live in a country where most people are religious, and most school teachers and children believe in some form of God, even if the teachers are not allowed to use their power of the students for religious purposes. I strongly suspect that as long as public schools continue to give tests, there will always be prayer in schools.

Upon pointing this out, I have been met with the reply that the increasing secularism of the school system has told God that he has not wanted and that he has withdrawn his “protective influence.” This is such a morally despicable notion. Are we expected to believe that God makes it possible for little children to be brutally murdered solely because adults no longer use the government to force feed kids religious teachings? Do the people who spew such rubbish from their mouths seriously believe that none of the murder victims at that Connecticut school house believed in God or sought his protection? It seems highly likely to me that at least one of the children believed in a God, and were otherwise innocent, and yet we are told that they had to die because God was not wanted at their school.

This of course comes from a man who rejects the notion that a God exists. I don’t blame removing God from our schools because I don’t think he was ever there in the first place. There is, of course, no evidence that any god or any protective influence exists. Such a thing has never been demonstrated. The occurrence and distribution of tragic events in time and space can be explained entirely by natural laws. Hurricanes hit god believers and sinners alike. Christians, atheists, Hindus, Muslims and Jews all die in mass shootings, bombings, acts of war and terrorism.

The apparent disinterest of God stands in stark contrast to the shameless, manipulative behavior of some of his most fervent, politically-active followers.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Politics and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s