Border Fascism: Conservatives and Immigration

Is it ironic that people who are allegedly in favor of reducing the role of government in our lives, are the ones who are most likely to get bent out of shape over people crossing the arbitrary lines governments draw.  I tend to find this mostly true of conservatives as libertarians general support the freedom of individuals to travel freely across the Earth’s surface.

I find when I talk to actual self-identified conservatives about the issue of immigration, what they often say is downright fascistic.  They may say, that they are in favor of immigration, but not illegal immigration (as if the distinction is anything but arbitrary or our laws on immigration are actually moral).  They make such a big deal about the supposedly illicit aspect of these people presence in the country, and they refer to them by the rather dehumanizing term “illegals”.  The problem is that are immigration laws have little to do with keeping out people who wish to live off the welfare system or commit crime and allowing people who are simply seeking work entry.  They instead produce a time consuming bureaucratic process, that makes entering the country illegally much easier than entering through recognized channels.  Of course, this also creates a class of easily exploitable cheap laborers who have to live in constant fear that their employers will turn them over to the state (and therefore have no recourse against any abuses they are subject to).  This may be good for people who wish to exploit vulnerable laborers but it is bad for everyone else.

The self-identified conservatives I speak to will also say things like “they are not coming here to be Americans”, which apparently they see as grounds for keeping immigrants out.  I find the idea that we should restrict the freedom of others to travel, in order to preserve some sort of cultural purity to be not only immoral but the epitome of big intrusive government.  At times the claim “they are not coming here to be Americans” also has a racist and xenophobic, aspect as well, depending on who is saying it.  Government should be completely neutral to cultural issues, as well as are language or racial makeup.

Overall, my understanding is that immigrants are generally good for an economy, as they are willing to do many jobs Americans are not interested in, and are happy to spend the money they make here, on goods and services, pumping that wealth back into the economy.  I tend to find it disingenuous when conservative politicians complain about immigrants taking jobs from Americans.  Often these are the same people who are doing everything in the world to make it easier for American companies to outsource to third world nations, and more often than not these politicians are indebted to the businessmen, who are benefiting from the vulnerable laborers are current system is producing.

We are a culture that was produced by countless waves of immigration, as such we should realize this process is still taking place, and that using the state to fight it, has the opposite of keeping government small.

This entry was posted in Politics and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Border Fascism: Conservatives and Immigration

  1. I am definitely not a conservative. I am definitely against illegal immigration. I have no idea where you live, but I could take you to a number of convenience stores in the Atlanta area where hispanic men stand around waiting to negotiate labor wages with prospective “employers.” When these “employers” pull up, the men gather around. The bidding begins. The lowest bidder gets the job. I know that they offer to work for less than minimum wage, which is illegal. They don’t pay taxes, the employer doesn’t pay their taxes. This process makes it hard for a law abiding citizen to compete in that particular market, as they, by law, are more expensive to employ. Let’s level the playing field by abolishing income taxes, payroll taxes, and minimum wages. Switch to a national sales tax. Then let the market sort out labor wages. That alone will go further to stem illegal immigration than “immigration reform.”

    As a side note, at what point do you stop allowing survivors onto a life raft? At some point, adding one more person on the raft will kill everyone. Isn’t immigration just the same? People are fleeing a drowning economy, an economy that has failed, that has ceased to provide enough jobs to keep them afloat. They are jumping onto a life raft, which in this case is the US. At some point, this raft will sink. Then where do we all go?

    • Mr. Wilson says:

      I have lived in multiple boarder states and have seen the scene you describe countless time. It sounds your chief objection to illegal immigration is that these immigrants have advantages over the rest of us in that they can work for less without the tax burden. You propose, we eliminate the advantages, but you still say that would “stem illegal immigration”. The thing is once you have eliminated all the advantages why not make these people’s stay in the country legal, and have the compete on a fair playing field??

      Is there some other reason you oppose illegal immigration or immigration in general that you are not mentioning?

      Also I reject your lifeboat analogy. These immigrants did not make their home economies sink. Their home countries suffered as a result of years, of land-theft, unstable military dictatorships, cronyist governments and centuries of violent coercion in general. Maybe I am wrong, but my understanding that the more people buying and selling goods and service in an economy the better it will work.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s